Opinion - CIOInsight
Home arrow Opinion arrow How Congress May Upset IT Executives
  Opinion


How Congress May Upset IT Executives
By Larry Downes


Rate This Article:
Add This Article To:
Some laws should never see the light of day. But if they're approved, they could be detrimental to IT executives, their organizations and users.

One benefit of the U.S. legislative process, which requires passage by the House and the Senate and approval by the President, is that poorly conceived and ill-advised laws often disappear along the way.

But not always. As Congress resumes work this month, there are plenty of punch-drunk bits of pending legislation IT executives have reason to fear. Consider these three examples:

Patent Reform Act—Passed by the House in September, the Patent Reform Act was unveiled in both chambers in April. The legislation makes a few significant changes, including a new administrative process for challenging a patent after it has been granted, and adjustments to the way damages are calculated that arguably favor established technology companies over start-ups.

Resource Library:

But most problematic about the bill is what it doesn't do: address any of the real problems in the very broken patent system. These include the granting of software and business process patents, the lack of any real IT expertise in the patent office, and the pooling and cross-licensing of dubious patents and "trolling" (enforcing patent infringements with no intent of manufacturing products), which together discourage the kinds of innovation the system is supposed to midwife.

PRO IP Act—The Prioritizing Resources and Organization for Intellectual Property Act, introduced in the House in December, would mean a giant step backward for users in the continuing battle over intellectual property rights. Recall that the Recording Industry Association of America won the first of its thousands of lawsuits that went to trial, leaving the defendant owing more than $200,000 for sharing 24 songs on a peer-to-peer network. But, at the lobbying request of content owners, this bill actually increases the penalties for copyright infringement.

In addition, the PRO IP Act would allow the federal government to sue for forfeiture of any property and, in some cases, property owned by third parties used or intended to be used to commit infringement. It also would establish an intellectual property enforcement representative in the White House, who would serve as the administration's worldwide ambassador and policy head for IP matters.

SAFE Act—The Securing Adolescents from Exploitation-Online Act, passed by the House in December, imposes on operators of "electronic communication services" and "remote computing services" the duty to report violations of child pornography laws that occur on their networks. That sounds reasonable until you learn that the definition of these "services," borrowed from the Patriot Act, includes not only your company network but even home WiFi connections.

And the definition of what constitutes child pornography, borrowed from last year's embattled Adam Walsh Act, is broad enough to cover images that are entirely computer-generated. Access providers who obtain "actual knowledge of any facts or circumstances" involving child pornography are required to report the details (along with any data or other "commingled" files), or face fines up to $300,000 per incident.

Some of these bills may not pass, and the worst mistakes in those that do pass may be corrected or nullified in time. Then again, even with all the legal system's checks and balances, these and other turkeys could become law. It's happened before.





Discuss How Congress May Upset IT Executives
 
>>> Be the FIRST to comment on this article!
 

 
 
>>> More Opinion Articles          >>> More By Larry Downes
 


 
 
FEATURED SPONSORED CONTENT

    VMware  Business Infrastructure Virtualization: 

    The Source for Virtualization, IT Efficiency and IT Agility.


    Learn how VMware is the source for the world’s most trusted, flexible and dynamic virtualization solutions, from the datacenter to the desktop to the cloud.

          Go To The Source

    Brought to You By

FEATURED SPONSORED MESSAGE

    Build A More Efficient Data Center

    Demands are growing but budgets are not. Solve your pressing IT issues using the resources you already have.


    Determine which technologies can help you drive efficiencies and how they are applied. Gain a quick ROI on new initiatives.

CIO STRATEGY
Tips for Implementing Your IT Strategy

Columbia University's Art Langer provides a playbook for executing your strategic IT plan.  

Sir Terrence Mathews and How to Grow Startups

RECENT NEWS

BIZTECH 3.0
By Brian P. Watson
What the M&A Wave Means for CIOs

Many analysts are predicting an uptick in M&A activity. CIOs: Are you ready to drop everything to handle te challenge?
KNOW IT ALL
By Ed Cone
Pulte CIO's Cloud Computing Horror Story

Tony Kontzer's post on the cloud gone wrong is drawing sharp comments from readers.

BOTTOM LINE
By Baseline Editors
How Can You Manage IT Projects Better?

IT project managers have their hands full today. What can they do make their work easier?
EDITORS' PICKS
 
 
LATEST STORIES

FEEDBACK

Ziff Davis Enterprise RSS Feeds
IT WHITE PAPERS
Technical WHITE PAPERS essential in the decision-making process for technology buyers!

See All White Papers

Sponsored Links
  • No Payments for Up to 6 Months on Orders over $500.
  • VMware. Business Infrastructure Virtualization.
  • up.time Easily Monitors Virtual/Physical/Cloud. Free Trial.
  • Find out 7 Ways to Drive Data Center Efficiency
  • Save up to 40% on calling costs with Avaya Aura™
  • Reduce risk, gain agility. See Progress Software.
  • ESET NOD32 Business Edition - Get your free trial now!
  • 10 Reasons to Upgrade to Windows Server 2008 R2.

  • eWEEK Quick LInks