Past Opinions - CIOInsight
Home arrow Past Opinions arrow Page 2 - Opinion: The Perils of Project Planning
  Past Opinions


Opinion: The Perils of Project Planning
By John Parkinson


  Table of Contents:
  1. Opinion: The Perils of Project Planning
  2. ' What Can Go Wrong '

Rate This Article:
Add This Article To:
Opinion: The Perils of Project Planning - ' What Can Go Wrong '
( Page 2 of 2 )


What can go wrong? The single biggest mistake I see planners make it to assume some aspect of "perfection" in their conversion of an estimate into a plan. Our estimates are not perfect; they need to encompass uncertainty. People are not peripherals: their performance is uneven and they can be distracted by many kinds of unplanned events. Efficient units of work don't always fit efficient division of required effort.

Planners need to take these things into account by introducing "slack": contingency time that can be consumed when adjustments are necessary but that accumulates when not used and can be "returned" to the available resources pool at the end of the project. At least that's the theory.

Resource Library:
Trouble is, slack tends to get used if it's available, whether it's needed or not. And if it's used but not needed it reduces productivity (because now it's just waste). So planners often "hide" the contingency from the team until it's needed, and that doesn't exactly foster an open and collaborative environment.

The second biggest mistake is to expect uniform productivity: the same amount of output from a day's input, every day. I have seldom seen this happen, even on projects that take a long time. It's much better to manage trends, where you can smooth the daily data into a useful indicator of progress, than to panic at the fluctuations on a daily basis.

Back in Project Management 101, we used to teach our teams to "plan the work and then work the plan." That's still not a bad basic approach in many circumstances. But it turns out that it isn't actually the best advice. Better would be to "plan the work and then adjust the plan as you go so that you get as close to the original commitments as you can." That's what effective self-organized teams do, and what pilots do when they file a flight plan. You have to have a plan to be allowed to make the flight (because you will be sharing scare resources with other flights), but it's really just a definition of what you intend to do, not an exact description of what will happen, which you can't predict exactly. Then you adjust as you go so that you get the safest result that's also the most cost effective, as nearly on time as possible.

This is called systems dynamics modeling, and there are interesting proofs that projects managed using these principles always ends sooner than they would have if they had been managed "statically": in other works, executed exactly as originally planned with no "in flight" deviations. The best project managers actually use this adjustment process intuitively (sometimes even when they aren't "allowed" to by the project planners). That's often why they are acknowledged as the best project managers: Their projects always seem to come in closest to expectations and without heroic efforts. (If you're interested in the theory behind system dynamics models, look for a copy of "Software Project Dynamics" by Tarek Abdel-Hamid and Stuart Madnick)

One very important caveat. Dynamically managed projects don't necessarily finish sooner than planned, or even on time. But they do (provably) finish as soon as possible in the context of whatever actually happens. It's very important to remember that distinction and be careful what you promise. All planning approaches have their perils.



 
 
>>> More Past Opinions Articles          >>> More By John Parkinson
 


 
 
FEATURED SPONSORED MESSAGE
 

    Free System Center Trial!

    Download the free System Center trial and see first-hand how it can help your company consolidate IT management tasks and optimize resources.


FEATURED SPONSORED MESSAGE

    Free Trial Download!

    Download SQL Server 2008 for a free trial and see how this global efficiency engine stores, sorts, mines, analyzes, reports, and manages any data -- and saves you time and money.


BIZTECH 3.0
By Brian P. Watson
CIOs and the Consumerization of IT

New advice on how CIOs should bring consumer-focused technologies into the enterprise.
CIO STRATEGY
The Perfect IT Book for the Business?

Parkinson needs a book that explains IT to the business. Got any suggestions?    

Google CIO on IT's Role in Corporate Culture

RECENT NEWS

KNOW IT ALL
By Tony Kontzer
Internet Addiction: A Mental Illness?

A leading psychiatric group doesn't think so. But maybe it should. 


EDITORS' PICKS
 
 
LATEST STORIES

FEEDBACK


Ziff Davis Enterprise RSS Feeds

Sponsored Links
  • Get Free BlackBerry® Enterprise Server Express
  • Cost-Saving, efficient VoIP solutions provided by CIMCO
  • Servers that cut energy costs by 95%? Cool.
  • Save time & money with Microsoft's cloud services.
  • Simplicity is Power. Start simplifying with Citrix.
  • Register for WES 2010 by March 26 and save $200.
  • One number. One voicemail. Sprint Mobile Integration.
  • CDW Healthcare offers the IT solutions you need.
  • FREE Sophos Encryption Tool: Encrypt, compress and share files easily.
  • eWEEK Quick LInks