Case Study: Tsutaya, a Tokyo Video Store, Goes MobileBy Alexandra Harney | Posted 02-22-2002
Case Study: Tsutaya, a Tokyo Video Store, Goes Mobile
Company | Tsutaya
Corporate Headquarters | Tokyo
Year founded/TOL* | 1999
Employees/TOL | 100
Subscribers/TOL | 2.15 million
Data warehoused | Gender, income, lifestyle, occupation and product, preferences of 16 million customers, collected since 1994 by parent firm CCC
Wireless technology platform | i-Mode
Parent company | Culture Convenience Club Ltd. (CCC, includes Tsutaya and TOL)
**CCC Revenue | $795.6 million in 2002, up 6.7% over $745.5 million 2001
**CCC Net income | $13.6 million in 2002, up 48.1% over $7.07 million in 2001
* Tsutaya Online
** estimated, March-to-March fiscal year; based on $1 = ¥132.06
TOKYOThe crowded, brightly-lit back alleys and winding thorough-fares of Tokyo's Shibuya district can, at night, resemble a futuristic fantasyland. Against the backdrop of neon-wrapped skyscrapers and noisy video billboards, groups of teenagersmany of them wearing Captain Kirk-like black pants and T-shirtssport orange hair, headsets and mobile-phone packs hanging from their belt loops like space-age weaponry. From coffee shop to train platform, people talk and type into cutting-edge mobile phones. The small, slender devices fold up like business card holders, have tiny, scaled-down, color screens that display complex graphics, and they're hotwired to the Web 24/7.
William Gibson, a science-fiction writer who was inspired by the "Tomorrowland" feel of Tokyo's urban landscape, once observed that "the future is already upon us, it is just unevenly distributed." If the mobile Internet is the future, then Tokyo is certainly where most of it is distributed right now, and Tsutaya, Japan's largest video and CD entertainment chain, is one of the more telling examples of what's possible with m-commerce. Tsutaya, which is the retail brand of parent company Culture Convenience Club Ltd., is not only proving with its online arm that it can use the mobile Internet to drum up more customers, manage costs and boost sales; it's showing others in the business world how a good database and always-on mobile Internet channels can help companies take the pulse of their customers anytime, anywhereliterally by reaching into their pockets, via i-Mode wireless services and devices, and data-tracking their whims.
The key is Tsutaya's ability to marry a rich database to mobility. Says Kirk Kramer, a Hong Kong-based vice president at Mercer Management Consulting: "Tsutaya realizes that being able to sample the population's pulse in real time is central to its success." Tsutaya founder Muneaki Masuda agrees: "We're not interested in merely renting videos to people. We're collecting lifestyle information, and the possibilities of that are, over time, enormous."
To be sure, the wireless Internet has failed to catch on in every part of the world except Japan. WAP, the wireless application protocol that was supposed to put mobile phone users on the Internet in the U.S. and Europe, has had a slew of problems, including slow access and even slower adoption. Yet Japan's i-Mode service, introduced in February 1999 by Japan's mobile telecom giant NTT DoCoMo Inc.and now being used by Tsutayahas attracted more than 30 million subscribers, or about one-fourth of Japan's population.
Critics attribute i-Mode's success to Japan's funky penchant for gadgetry and its sprawling metropolitan areas, which force millions of people onto commuter trains with little to do for as many as four hours a day. But i-Mode's popularity has more to do with DoCoMo's understanding of how to set up a mobile data serviceand the savvy of a handful of companies, like Tsutaya, that have figured out how to weave i-Mode service into an already smart mix of techno weaponry in the rivalry for market share. (See "Thinking Out Loud.")
It helps, of course, that Japan has one of the highest mobile phone usage rates in the worldone mobile phone for every two peopleand the most advanced mobile telecommunications infrastructure. It may take a while for the U.S. to catch up, says Mark A. Berman, a telecom analyst at Credit Suisse First Boston in Tokyo. But the trend is irreversible: By 2004, researchers predict, the number of mobile Internet users around the world will rise to around 1 billion, from 200 million today, chiefly in Europe and Japan. Says Adrian Slywotzky, an author, lecturer and consultant on digital businesses: "Wireless mobility is the technology strategy of the decade. Anyone not thinking about how wireless can help their company is simply not looking ahead."
How does Tsutaya do it? Partly, it's due to a sizeable customer database, which parent CCC built in 1994, way ahead of most rivals. But Tsutaya has also figured out new ways to use that information. Tying it to mobile phones has put so-called customer relationship management into hyper-drive. By combining data with mobility via i-Mode service, Tsutaya is able to maintain a dynamic, always-on picture of individual entertainment tastes and preferencesand then personalize product offeringsthe elusive dream of one-to-one marketing come home to roost. Says Kramer: "When mobile commerce came along, Tsutaya asked, 'How can we now use our database in a new way to serve customers?'"
How does it all work for the consumer? Suppose your 13-year-old daughter bought the latest CD by *NSYNC, a popular boy band. When the band's next release is available, Tsutaya Online (TOL), Tsutaya's wireless i-Mode site, will e-mail you a digital music clip. Similarly, fans of movie star Nicole Kidman can be sent a review of her new movie, "Birthday Girl,'' and then track its availability on video via the Web or mobile phone. And now, Tsutaya also has what it calls a "recommendation engine" that can match the title of the films you last watched and their typesentimental, violent, scaryand then suggest something new. Want a love story, tear-jerker or horror film? Happy ending or sad? TOL lets you chooseand then uses that information to further segment your tastes and off-work interests.
Tsutaya's information-intensive business model helps to control costs, too. Managers can quickly identify slow-moving video rentals, for example, so they can be sold off to a subsidiary. Telling Tsutaya customers how many videos of a certain title are in stock at any given time also cuts down on wasted store visits by customers. Furthermore, it saves the company money by reducing the time clerks spend checking on product availability.
Still not convinced? Check out the numbers. TOL is Japan's most popular online entertainment site, with 50 million page views per month. On average, Tsutaya's online customers spend 9 percent more per month than those who shop offline, and people who are e-mailed movie reviews and video clips via the Web and mobile phones tend to rent two to five times more films than nonsubscribers. TOL's online services also have helped to increase brick-and-mortar parent Tsutaya revenues, and TOL, too, is in the black. Online operating profits have grown from minus $2.8 million in fiscal 2000 to $357,283 for fiscal 2001a first-time profit for TOL, despite Japan's sluggish economy. And for the fiscal year ending in March 2002, parent CCC expects to rack up the equivalent of $13.6 million in net profits on revenues of $795.6 millionup by 6.7 percent over last year, thanks in large part to Tsutaya.
Tsutaya wasn't always so bold. Its digital strategy was the product of a management mishap. Masuda founded Culture Convenience Club as a video rental store in November 1985; by the 1990s, it had grown into the largest video, game, book and CD retail chain in Japan. But Masuda wasn't content to sit still.
In 1996, he saw an opportunity in DirecTV, the satellite-broadcasting network that began operations in Tokyo in 1997. He became president of DirecTV in Japan, and took a team of CCC employees with him. But the relationship between CCC and DirecTV soured quickly, and by late 1998, according to TOL business strategy chief Takashi Miya, some of the 20 CCC executives that moved to DirecTV with Masuda were suddenly laid off internally, meaning their jobs were eliminated but they remained on the payroll. While that was bad for the executives, it provided the impetus for a digital strategy for the chain. Masuda soon redeployed them to create an online strategy for the entire chain as part of a new venture known as Tsutaya Online. "It all started by accident, really," admits Masuda. "Without the DirecTV disaster, there might not have been any Tsutaya Online." The whole experience, he says, "opened our eyes to the Internet and mobile commerce."
Tsutaya was late to hop onto the Internet bandwagon. "We were late in getting into PC-based online shopping, so we had to distinguish ourselves somehow," recalls Kouichi Shinozaki, general manager of mobile strategies for TOL. "At that time, Internet-equipped cell phones were just coming out, and people seemed to like them. So we decided to make our push in cell phones instead," he added. Proof, in retrospect, that first-mover advantage isn't always a plus in the long-run.
From the start, Tsutaya's push to go digital was always a collaboration between technology and marketing. Jun Hongo, TOL's chief technology officer, oversaw the early strategy, and he quickly assembled a mobile Internet team, composed of a mix of former bureaucrats, ex-investment bankers, and marketing and technology recruits from Panasonic Corp. The team met frequently with the marketing group to outline a digital strategy to distinguish Tsutaya.
Most of the technology they looked at was pretty simple: i-Mode sites use HTML, the programming language used on the PC-based Internet; the servers were supplied by NEC, and the database was managed by Oracle software. But there was intense debate over strategy. Some members of the mobile team wanted the site to allow customers to buy online; others feared that the Internet would cannibalize Tsutaya's traditional business. Marketing surveys taken in early 1999 bore out the dilemma: Most customers surveyed weren't even interested in shopping online. Only 8 percent actually wanted to buy CDs advertised online; 92 percent preferred to visit a real store.
Ultimately, a hybrid strategy emerged. "The data convinced us that most people use the Internet to collect information in order to make the decision to buy a CD, but the actual transaction was made at the storefront," says Miya. "But the 8 percent who wanted to buy onlinethose were latent customers. They were too busy to come to our stores, so they'd either buy online or not at all. It was a hidden market, one not tapped yet by us. So it was this untapped marketnot the cannibalizationwe ended up fearing we'd lose from the rise of the Internet."
Today, Tsutaya's Web site combines free and paid content, and essentially serves as a 24-hour customer tracking tool: The company's servers record nearly every move users make on TOL sites in near real-time. By getting customers to register their personal data online, the site has also created another database of information on 2.15 million Web-based subscribers, about 60 percent of whom access the site from a mobile phone. And depending on the urgency of the request, TOL can answer a set of questions posed by a movie studio or artists' rep about the demand curve on their products within 24 hours. At the same time, the data allows Tsutaya to tailor its marketing to the customer, while constantly collecting data on his or her behavior.
Tsutaya's strategy reflects five key innovations. First, the team introduced mail-maga Japanese-English for "mail magazine"that can be sent to an e-mail account on a mobile phone or PC detailing upcoming releases of books, music and video games. They are popular: TOL sends out 26 million mail-magas every month. To subscribe, an i-Mode user goes to TOL's site and chooses from a selection of magazines. One magazine, MOVIC, details new releases of both movies and music. Others, like those on individual artists from Madonna to Morning Musume, a popular Japanese all-girl band, are more narrowly focused.
The e-mail magazines have reduced customer churn: According to DoCoMo wireless strategy director Takeshi Natsuno, they've helped to double the number of visits by Tsutaya customers to the company's brick-and-mortar stores. A subscriber's choice of one magazine gives TOL more information about subscriber preferences. At the same time, subscribersby reserving and ordering favorite CDs and movies onlinegive Tsutaya a bird's-eye view into future sales and marketing trends.
TOL's second innovation was its online reservations service. Members can reserve copies of books, movies and video games ahead of their release, and have them delivered to their home or office, or even to the nearest Tsutaya store. Eighty percent of Tsutaya members use the Internet (Web and mobile), compared with more than 40 percent of the general Japanese population as of January, according to Nielsen//Net Ratings. Between 10 percent to 20 percent of Tsutaya's brick-and-mortar customers are also TOL members. Besides increasing store traffic and boosting customer loyalty, the reservation system also cuts Tsutaya's overhead costs. "It frees up the guy behind the counter," says Mercer's Kramer. "It's exactly what the automated teller machine did for banking, and any little improvement in efficiency drops to the bottom line."
The third leg of Tsutaya's technology strategy is its online coupon program. TOL's first president, Shinsuke Fujimoto, dreamed up the idea one day when sharing a midnight snack with friends at Yoshinoya, a 24-hour beef-and-rice fast-food chain. Yoshinoya gave him a coupon for a discount meal, and Fujimoto wondered why TOL couldn't offer the same kind of coupon. The result: TOL sends personalized discount offers to customers via their mobile phones and PCs. Been a while since you visited a Tsutaya store? The company will send you a special offer on your mobile phone that's only good at your neighborhood store. To redeem it, you bring in your mobile phone, show the clerk the special offer on the screen, and you can get a 10 percent discount on the latest Tori Amos recording.
The company has since extended its coupon strategy to include marketing partners such as Ryohin Keikaku, a retailer that operates a discount goods chain selling everything from soap to clothing to televisions. Its first joint coupon with the chain, issued in December 2000, attracted nearly 60,000 hits for a 10 percent, 10-day discount on any of the retailer's products.
Tsutaya says that about 100,000 people use the coupon service every month. The payoff? Coupon users, on average, visit Tsutaya shops 22 percent more frequently, and spend 7 percent more overall than coupon-less customers, Miya says.
Now, Tsutaya is starting to experiment with a fourth innovation, variable pricinggathering and then isolating a specific population, tracking its habits via mobile Internet, then sending it highly customized offerings for free product trials, a type of real-time focus group community on which to test new products. When Kirin, the Japanese beer company, wanted to introduce a new brew two years ago, it asked TOL to conduct a survey of customers who frequent Tsutaya's store in Shibuya. TOL sent customers a link to a coupon for a free beer tasting at the Shibuya store. Visitors were then encouraged to fill out a survey on their mobile phones detailing whether they liked the new beer, Kirin Lager Special Light, and why they might buy it. Says Shinozaki: "Our ability to target certain segments of the population allowed us to charge [Kirin] a higher price, and the response rate to our survey was very high." The company has done similar promotions for companies in other industries, like shampoo manufacturers, but now it sees the market research option as a potentially lucrative source of new revenues.
In the future, Tsutaya might also use its coupon strategy to selectively reduce inventory. "Say Tsutaya knows that certain people buy American action films, and then discovers that they have excess inventory of exactly that type of film piling up somewhere," says retail analyst Hideki Goto of Deutsche Bank Tokyo. "All Tsutaya would have to do is send those American action flick fans a discount coupon, and they can eliminate their inventory very quickly."
The fifth and newest part of Tsutaya's digital strategy is a new search engine called TOMAS (Tsutaya Online My Agent System). It's aimed at guessing customer needs and tastes in videos and books based on past purchases. But unlike Amazon.com, Tsutaya's service combines customer data collected by the company online with data collected offline. And TOMAS is mobileletting customers tap into their mobile phones or PCs to rate and choose movies, books, videos and CDs. How up close and personal does TOMAS get? Pretty close. Miya says the company's database is now so sophisticated, it can differentiate between customers most likely to want very grisly war movies, for example, from those who prefer war movies with less violenceand use that data to more finely personalize what users find on their screens when they're shopping for a movie. "Other search engines would group these two types of people together, but TOMAS allows us to distinguish between them," says Miya.
It's another way that Tsutaya is using evermore refined technologies to collect new details on customer habits and tastes and then crunch them more finely than before. "People's images about the lifestyle they want drive consumption, and all we are doing is turning those desires into a business," Miya says. "Making it all mobile helps us understand impulse buying and a new aspect of customer behavior."
Tough Hurdles Ahead
Tough Hurdles Ahead
Can success last? Last October, when DoCoMo launched third-generation wireless Internet servicesso-called 3G services that allow for faster transfers of graphics to mobile phonesTOL started providing customers real movie clips. But 3G is still clunky and expensive, even in Japan, and the service has yet to really take off. The potential growth in broadband Internet access also worries Tsutaya's top executives, who say it could upset the cozy relationship between Tsutaya's online and offline operations by making it easier for customers to simply download music and movies from home, bypassing their i-Mode services altogether. (See "Trouble On the Line.")
And then there's the Japanese recession. Corporate restructuring is driving Japan's jobless rate to new highs: In December, the latest month for which data is available, unemployment hit a record 5.6 percent. Some retailers, like supermarket chain Daiei Inc., are facing bankruptcy.
But Masuda isn't too concerned. "Taking a family to the movies in Japan costs ¥5,000 ($37)," Masuda says, "but renting a DVD from us costs ¥300, or roughly $2.25. We thrive in a deflationary environment."
He may be right, at least for now. One recent evening in Tokyo's futuristic Shibuya neighborhood, Tsutaya's six-story store was hummingliterally. Deutsche Bank's Goto calls the store an example of Tsutaya's expertise in lifestyle marketing. Packed with a mobile phone retail outlet, a Starbucks coffee shop, rows of listening booths and boxes of electronics, the showcase store combines the messy feel of a fraternity house with the high-tech buzz of the classic 1982 film Blade Runner. Young Japanese with variously dyed hair and camouflage pants crowd each other in the aisles as the latest pop music blares from hidden speakers. Says market analyst Goto: "They've got it right. Their brand image is well-established. They're catching people on the go and getting them into the stores at the same time." Masuda credits mobility. "The technology is now there to track your customers 24/7," he says. "The possibilities are endless."
ALEXANDRA HARNEY writes for the Financial Times, most recently from Toyko. Comments on this story can be sent to firstname.lastname@example.org.
The Mobile Wireless Internet Forum, an international nonprofit industry association to drive development of global wireless technology standards.
The largest directory of mobile Internet sites.
Nokia-owned news and information site about the mobile Internet.
The Mobile Internet: How Japan Dialed up and the West Disconnected
By Jeffrey Lee Funk. ISI Publications Ltd., 2001.
M-Business: The Race to Mobility
By Ravi Kalakota and Marcia Robinson. McGraw-Hill, 2001.